Star rating - 7/10
It must be
one of the biggest hazards of making a film about the recent past, that real life
events will overtake the story during the production. That is exactly what
happened to Kathryn Bigelow when she was making her follow up to the stupendous
war portrait Hurt Locker. Zero Dark Thirty was intended to tell
the story of the failed hunt by the CIA for al Qaeda chief Osama bin Laden. So it must have
been inconvenient and pretty costly when two thirds of the movie complete, they
went and killed him in real life (and yes I know some people dispute that this ever
happened but let's just go with it for now).
The two
thirds finished product obviously had to be completely rewritten to track the news. And perhaps this is a lesson that a little more time should
be allowed to pass before the film maker's lens should examine recent history. I have got to say I am a little mystified and
a tad disappointed at the result. For example, Bigelow
has gone on record as being totally against the use of torture of prisoners - the
problem is that you wouldn't know that from watching this film. Not
surprisingly, it is not being released in Pakistan, as it is definitely a US-tinted
version of events, without the distance and humanitarian stance of her previous
film.
As a piece it
is thrillingly well made, which is no mean feat, as we all know how this tale
ends. And it is extremely well acted - Jessica Chastain is superb as the
central CIA agent on a one woman mission to capture bin Laden against all the
odds. Sadly you can't help but make comparisons of her character to that of Carrie
Mathison in Homeland, and Carrie was first and best in my book. It almost seems
a bit of a caricature following in Homeland's footsteps - a strong woman, with
no friends or close relationship, in an obsessional search for a high level
terrorist target, often in total opposition to her superiors- it's all a bit clichéd
now.
And will you
allow me to have a trivial moan? - good - then all I will ask is why is Mark Strong,
a good actor and even better looking chap, made to wear a wig? All I could
think of while he was on screen was the wig. And his American accent was a bit
of a curate's egg - good in parts.
So Zero Dark Thirty has nothing like the
impact of The Hurt Locker due to its compromised subject matter - but is a
thrilling watch nevertheless.
No comments:
Post a Comment